I normally like Catholic Vote. In regards this article I agree with the essence of the teaching. But sometimes I fell that the Catholic stance on some topics may be idealistic versus having all the facts and understanding why some torture occurred in specific circumstances. War is hell, and where the enemy has unyielding intent to kill, drastic measures are sometimes necessary and often save lives; neither is it torture for the subtle enjoyment of it; and, there are varying degrees--from enhanced interrogation to chopping off a body part (not to mention in comparison how the enemy treats us). Today we have been reviewing the report released by the Senate intelligence committee detailing interrogation practices used in the past by the CIA in the war on terror. The report contains some truly disturbing findings, including details on practices that were truly inexcusable and inhumane. The truth is some members of our CIA engaged in activities intended to protect America that have no place in any civil society -- and we unequivocally oppose and condemn these actions by our government. Writer Jim Manzi wrote years ago that “a decent society needs to defend itself from armed aggression without becoming a society not worth defending. This is never simple to accomplish.” Saint John Paul the Great described torture as an ‘intrinsically evil’ act. In such acts he explained “a good intention or particular circumstances can diminish their evil, but they cannot remove it. They remain ‘irremediably evil acts; per se and in themselves they are not capable of being ordered to God and to the good of the person.’” Part of the greatness of America is that we DO hold ourselves to such high standards. We are right to subject our government and its leaders to heavy scrutiny. And when our government fails the universal test of human dignity, we demand justice. And rightly so. Some people have pointed out that the timing of the release of this report was political. The preparation of the report has been clouded in controversy. But that doesnt change the facts. Based on confirmed reports, the CIA has acknowledged that it made mistakes and the political fallout has only just begun. We readily admit that there are some difficult questions involved in interrogations. What constitutes torture can at times be difficult to define. But what is not up for debate is that there have been cases where government officials have crossed the line. As one example, regardless of whether you believe waterboarding is torture, surely subjecting a person to the practice 183 times is indefensible. Or practices that brought our own interrogators to tears. Torture is a violation of the dignity of the human person. Every human is made in the image and likeness of God. The actions by those who engaged in torture, however well intended, or whether helpful intelligence was garnered in the process, does not excuse their actions. Those who have fought to defend America have done so with both valor, and at times, with moral restraint. Their service remains worthy of our deepest esteem.
Posted on: Sat, 13 Dec 2014 07:37:50 +0000
Trending Topics
Recently Viewed Topics
© 2015