POPULAR AHADEETH WHICH ARE WIDESPREAD AND HAVE NO BASIS When he (The Messenger - Sallallahu ‘Alaihi wa salam) came to Madina, the Women and children began to sing: ‘Tala’al Badru ‘Alainaa’ (The full moon has risen upon us) ‘Min Thaneeyaatil Wadaa’ (From Thaneeyatil Wadaa’(one of the entrances into Madina)) ‘Wajabash Shukru ‘Alainaa’ (Giving thanks is mandatory upon us) ‘Maa Da’aa Lillahi Daa’ (As long as there is a caller calling to Allah) Ruling: Weak (Collected by Abul Hasan al khala’ee in Al Fawaa’id 2/59 and Baihaqi in ‘Dalaa’il 2/233 there are three missing narrators from its chain so it is considered ‘Mu’dhal’) Ibnil Qayyim rejects this claim with his statement: “It is clear conjecture, because thaneeyatul Wadaa’ is in the direction of shaam (Syria, Jordon region) hence the one who comes from Makkah to Madinah, doesnt even see it! except if he heads towards Shaam“ (Zaadul Ma’aad 3/13) Imaam Ghazaali mentions the story with the addition ‘..while playing the Duff and singing‘ Imaam Al ‘Iraaqi mentions rebutting this: “There is no mention of The Duff and singing in it!“
Posted on: Wed, 04 Sep 2013 16:34:03 +0000
Trending Topics
© 2015