Every posek says its assur, but nobody can agree as to why. Theres - TopicsExpress



          

Every posek says its assur, but nobody can agree as to why. Theres a sense that permitting electricity would make Shabbos like chol, so they forbid it - exactly as Rambam describes. שביתה הניכרת. To use a more mundane example (from R. Moshe Stav of KBY): Why did they put Al Capone in jail? Everyone says tax evasion, but its not true. They put him in jail because he was a gangster. The legal mechanism by which they did it was tax evasion. - Elli Fischer Jeffrey Woolf
Posted on: Wed, 01 Oct 2014 23:21:17 +0000

Trending Topics



Recently Viewed Topics




© 2015