Question : Why do you use the term Madkhali and which scholar has permitted you to use them? Answer : Madkhali is a tribal name not a copyright product of shaykh rabee ibn hadee hafidhahullah or shaykh zaid rahimahullah. Secondly, the salafis before 1990 were never like this. Obviously then this hijack upon the manhaj by innovating this new policy by the SPUBS and their ILK backed by some scholars of arabia like sh rabee himself, is an innovation against the manhaj of salafiyyah. Anyone who has or was a student of knowledge in the early 90s knows this very well. Anyone who wasnt also knows this very well. The current scholars (other than the limited handful 5-6 of arabia) of the globe are so fed up with this new innovated manhaj boosted and innaugrated by shaykh rabee and some others along with him since 1992 that we have come to an era where the term Madkhali is used by every sect both Muslims as well as NOn Muslims. Even the CIA reports have been using these names for distinguishing them from the salafis. they clearly used two labels salafis and second Madkhalis. If you see the old cassettes of the shuyukh in saudi arabia being asked questions about this madkhali term or business you will notice even there, they made a distinction between salafis and madkhalis and these are old tapes from 90s or early 2000. Now, it is but obvious and natural that shaykh rabee had a hand in encouraging and nurturing SPUBS and their ilk since decades now. This is all the more evident because they claim how shaykh rabee is aware of everything or almost everything across the globe and on the basis of this they many -a-times- seek a tazkiyah for any da`ee or otherwise from shaykh rabee (as they assume he MUST be aware of this individual) When it is known that sh rabee has had a very parenting hand over spubs and their ilk since decades and even till date none of the scholars (whom they consider as scholars) have come out in the open refuting them BY NAME except few which include shaykh waseeullah abbas hafidhahullah its been 20 years now. How long to wait before shaykh rabee or sh ubayd come and refute spubs when on the contrary they have praised it many many times in their audio ? so if a scholar praises spubs what do we make of it? Then why shouldnt we call them MADKHALIS when shaykh rabee has been the point of source for all this and this innovated manhaj? Now coming to the second part. Lets say we dont use this internationally accepted term. So what do we use? do we keep saying some brothers or do we say spubs (when not every madkhali agrees with spubs) or do we say xyz or do we make a new label? what do we do to distinguish them? Give us a solution Third part : scholars did not allow using this label. Excuse us, but since when did it become a rule or a council decision agenda to approve of a label? do they issue certificates of acknowledgement? or permit allowance? if the scholars or non scholars use labels to identify different sects and groups then why cant we? Or is it like the USA foreign policy when we do it, its fine but when you do it, its not ? Final part there are hundreds of thousands of scholars and senior students of knowledge. thousands or more of them on social media alone . we have personally used this term madakhila in front of many scholars from different ethinic background. Also, if you are literally that ignorant to actually ask us to hand over an excel sheet of scholars we learn from or more GENERALLY TAKE FROM, then all we can say is salam ! we learn from the muhaqiqeen, the muhadditheen, the sullaf, the khuttab , the this and that. we are students who learn from different grades and levels of aalim e deen. we dont restrict ourselves to saudi or kuwaiti or yemeni scholars alone. the spectrum of academia is vast . there are scholars in egypt, in morocco, in tunisia, in india, in pakistan, in bangladesh, in malaysia, in indonesia, in etc etc. ofcourse this does not mean we take from the sufis or shi`as or their kinds but be reasonable ya akhi. What copy right logic is this ? How many scholars have you taken from apart from youtube, blogger, wordpress and html? be honest and fear allah ! In the end all we say is, this particular hijack and its hijackers are known to be different since 2 decades now. Either we use the already accepted term madakhila or you give us another solution.
Posted on: Sat, 02 Aug 2014 15:33:52 +0000
Trending Topics
Recently Viewed Topics
© 2015