Yet Another Website Kills Comments, Despite Study Showing You Can Have Civil Comments If You Give A Damn Theres a trend afoot among some website editors to kill the comment section, then proclaim that theyve courageously decided to reduce conversation to help improve conversation. Its a random bit of logic weve noted doesnt make any sense if youre interested in actually fostering a local community, and care about not having all conversation outsourced to Facebook. The pretense that youre killing comments because youre nobly trying to further human communications (and not, say, because your website is cheap and lazy) is also disingenuous. That hasnt stopped ReCode, Reuters, Popular Science, or some newspapers from killing comments in order to push humans to the next evolutionary level (or whatever). This week, yet another website joined the comments are evil and have no use parade. In a now familiar treatise, TheWeek announced that while editors truly do value your opinions, youre no longer going to be allowed to express them on their website. According to TheWeek, this nuclear option was required because comments are just filled with horrible, nasty people: There was a time — not so long ago! — when the comments sections of news and opinion sites were not only the best place to host these conversations, they were the only place. That is no longer the case. Too often, the comments sections of news sites are hijacked by a small group of pseudonymous commenters who replace smart, thoughtful dialogue with vitriolic personal insults and rote exchanges of partisan acrimony. This small but outspoken group does a disservice to the many intelligent, open-minded people who seek a fair and respectful exchange of ideas in the comments sections of news sites. Of course if news outlets spent a few minutes actually moderating the comments section and treating it like a valuable community resource (instead of oh, a drunk uncle with a bad goiter and nasty halitosis at your wedding), that probably wouldnt be as big of a problem. In fact, its worth noting that a recent paper published in the Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication found that its not very hard to increase civility in your comment section. In some cases all it took was the writer of the article entering the comment section and treating the people there relatively well, even if theyre all busy acting like jackasses: One surprisingly easy thing they found that brought civil, relevant comments: the presence of a recognized reporter wading into the comments. Seventy different political posts were randomly either left to their own wild devices, engaged by an unidentified staffer from the station, or engaged by a prominent political reporter. When the reporter showed up, “incivility decreased by 17 percent and people were 15 percent more likely to use evidence in their comments on the subject matter,” according to the study. Note by recognized the paper just means somebody relatively recognized from the outlet or the reporter themselves. They also tried their very best to actually define incivility as a quantifiable metric: To develop a list of characteristics that signaled incivility, we drew from past research on the characteristics of uncivil discourse (Papacharissi, 2004; Sobieraj & Berry, 2011). To be coded as uncivil, the comment needed to include one or more of the following attributes: (1) Obscene language / vulgarity (e.g. “A@$#***les”), (2) Insulting language / name calling (e.g. “you idiots”), (3) Ideologically extreme language (e.g. “Liberal potheads”), (4) Stereotyping (e.g. “Deport them illegals”), or (5) An exaggerated argument (e.g. It’s very easy to solve all of this just keep your legs closed if you don’t want a baby.”). Comments containing any one of these characteristics were coded as uncivil. Having been a blogger (and a moderator of one of the Internets larger tech forums) for more than fifteen years, I can anecdotally note that even the biggest jackasses generally do dial back the antisocial angst when you calmly and politely talk to them (whether Ive always been able to do that every day without piling on antisocial angst of my own is another discussion). But between actual involvement and reasonable moderation, its not hard to reclaim a comment section from the encroaching, troll-induced apocalyptic jungle. What websites that close comment sections are doing is telling everyone they dont give quite enough of a shit to work to improve them. Proceeding to proclaim this is just because you really love conversation informs that same community you also think theyre kind of stupid.Permalink | Comments | Email This Story
Posted on: Wed, 24 Dec 2014 13:02:13 +0000
Trending Topics
Recently Viewed Topics
© 2015