Shaykh Hamdi Abdul Majeed as-Salafi Words On Shaykh Ali & Shaykh Rabee Rather, Shaykh Rabī’ claims that Shaykh ’Ali al-Halabī: “defends the unity of religions and praises those who call to it and fights against those who criticise it”. As for Shaykh Rabī’s reason for making tabdī’ of the brother ’Ali Hasan, may Allāh preserve him, and accusing him of what was mentioned prior, then the first we came across it was when the brother ’Ali published Shaykh Rabī’s advice to Shaykh Fālih al-Harbī, who was with him and then split from him. Shaykh ’Ali did not mention who was the author of the advice was, based on the general benefit, just as he did not ascribe himself as being the author of that advice, he explained the advice and commented on it in his book Manhaj Salaf us-Sālih and answered the most prominent points which can be taken from it in the second edition of the book, and other than which was mentioned on the kulsalafiyeen forum. From the vilest of things which has been said about Shaykh ’Ali is in regards to his stance towards the Amman Message. Shaykh Rabī’ in his article Hukm man yasghūgh deenan ghayr Deen il-Islām fa yarā Hurriyat ul-Adyān, applies the hukm on the brother Shaykh ’Ali al-Halabī, to Allāh we came and unto Him we shall return. This ascription to Shaykh al-Halabī is a false accusation against him as Shaykh ’Ali explained on numerous occasions such as in his answers to the brother Sādiq al-Baydānī from the Dār ul-Athar Channel. In these answers Shaykh ’Ali affirms the kufr of the one who says the unity of religions, and says this over and over again however, Shaykh Rabī’ ignored that and continued to accuse him [i.e. Shaykh ’Ali Hasan al-Halabī] of this bātil.
Posted on: Fri, 04 Oct 2013 11:11:47 +0000
Trending Topics
Recently Viewed Topics
© 2015