The Trouble with Truth After hearing a gun shot, a young lady ran into a neighbor’s home. As she stood in the doorway of the strange home, she saw a body on the floor and a man in the doorway across the room. He was about five foot seven inches tall and was putting a large gun away into his belt with his left hand. After putting the gun away he took a comb out of his left rear pocket and combed his hair with his left hand. After raking through his medium to short hair with the comb, he put the comb back into his left rear pocket with his left hand. The young lady could not see the man’s face but from the color of his arm he must have been middle-eastern; he was very dark, but not of African descent. The young lady turned and ran to her home across the street and called the police. While waiting for the police, she peered out her window at the neighbor’s home. In about three minutes a woman left by the front door of her neighbor’s home. This woman was very tall with a long sleeve blouse on and she had slacks and shoulder length, black hair and a dark complexion like the man the young lady had seen earlier. The dark woman ran down the street and around the corner and disappeared. When the police came the young lady ran across the street to tell them what had happened. After giving the police a full description of the two people she had seen at her neighbor’s home, she went back to her home completely confident she had gotten all her facts straight. Then she sat back to await the full details on the evening news. She was well satisfied by the news because all the details that she had given the police were on and they had even used her name. As time went on, the young lady was called in from time to time to identify possible suspects. There were several of the suspects that sort of fit the description, but none that were right. After several months the police stopped calling her to come in. The policed had run out of suspects. The problem was that the young lady from across the street had seen the same criminal she had seen that day in several line-ups. She had not recognized the perpetrator in the line-up because the truth of the crime was only the perceived truth. The truth as she had seen it was not the actual truth. The criminal was a right-handed Anglo-Saxon, more than six feet tall and there was no woman involved in the crime at all. How could she be so mistaken about the crime? It was easy; when she entered the unfamiliar house, she did not know that she was looking into a mirror in a doorway across the room. That which she saw as left, war really right, so the left-handed man was really right-handed. Also, the mirror was tilted slight upward so that the man appeared to be shorter than he really was. His Middle Eastern complexion came from working for several months in the sun. The tall woman leaving the house was really the very same man, who had put on a bra and blouse and covered his head with the victim’s wig. Because the young lady would not relent in her very “Accurate” description, the criminal went unpunished. She was very sure that she had noted everything and that she was correct, and she “WAS” correct. She was highly accurate in the truth as she perceived it. That is the problem with perceived truth. We know it is correct because we believe it to be correct, and we believe it to be correct because we have been convinced by something or someone. Now here’s the problem: not all perceived truths are something other than the truth; some perceived truths are really true. But, all perceived truths should be questioned and researched and put to the test of REASON and LOGIC. For each of us the hard part is in questioning our own perceived truths, some of which we hold dear, or perceived truths we learned from our parents. It is very tough work questioning our parents’ teachings or our own beliefs in the search for actual truth. It is even harder work when the answer we seek might come out to our own detriment. Thomas Hobbes said, “Such truth as opposeth no man’s profit nor pleasure is to all men welcome.” But, each of us must determine that which we are seeking: our own self-esteem, vanity, ego, pleasure, profit or truth . . . no matter where it leads and no matter its outcome. With hard evidence the truth is much easier to come upon; with thought and philosophies truth might be illusive or even nonexistent. Hence, we have many divergent thoughts, philosophies and religions. One must seek truth in their own thought, philosophy and religion and render it down to the point that they can live comfortably with it, and to the point that works for them. But, one must always keep in mind that truth is alive and moving and will change from time to time. That which was true yesterday, may or may not be true today or tomorrow. New evidence and reasoning expand with our mental capacity and that is expanded within each of us, through mental exercise. One must never stop questioning and exploring their own thoughts and ideas. This acts like a filter, and one might be surprised at what gets caught in the filter. It is usually a lot of garbage that you want to throw out anyway. But make sure the truth is not caught and thrown away if your sieve is too fine. If we didn’t believe there was a truth then we wouldn’t be asking questions. Sometimes questions are as important as the answers because it is through the proper questions that we get to that most elusive truth. So, there is something to be said for the process of finding the truth. Many prize the process of arriving at the truth more highly than the truth. They realize that the truth could change but the process will always stay the same or at least stable. Now we come to Functional truth. Functional truth is a suborder of perceived truth. If an innocent person is found guilty and that finding is never overturned, society goes on unaffected by this finding. Things go on seemingly unchanged by this new truth. The functional truth is that he is guilty. It was once believed that the world was flat, that the Sun revolved around the Earth, that the Earth was the center of the Universe and accepting these functional truths, little was changed. Today, many believe that there is no life other than on earth. I am sure that someday that will be looked upon as our functional truth. One must remember, there are no easy answers and as important, no easy questions. Questions are easy only if you know the answers and tailor your questions to fit. Abandon the easy answer and the easy question; let the process do its job. Always remember, don’t ask the question if you are not prepared to handle the answers. THAT IS THE TROUBLE WITH TRUTH.
Posted on: Sun, 30 Jun 2013 07:59:28 +0000
Trending Topics
Recently Viewed Topics
© 2015